"Very interesting.

Thank you for sharing the same".

Best Wishes,


"Just a short notice of my feeling when I think about our film, your work and

our cooperation" .

Thomas, 17.07.2007

"Dear Ms Malini Shankar

I read with interest the piece you have done on the Denotified Tribes. The research is excellent and so also your narration. I appreciate your style of writing and the sincerity with which you have approached the issue. Many thanks for such a good piece. Keep it up"

R S Deshpande

Feedback: Relocation of settlements is healing Sariska

"The 21 families that have been relocated should get a taste of modernity through the newly constructed houses, in other words they have not entirely been displaced. It better than been handed Rs10,000. How about the psychological trauma of post relocation? Will the NGOs handle that as well? Well I should say Congratulations to the NTCA for achieving this after the intense politics of it. Well done Malini on your article. Its refreshing".

Usman Jimada


It has become very clear that time and again the authorities have failed to take appropriate actions on time. By instinct we are supposed to learn from the mistakes that we make however in this regard the authorities have turned a blind eye on wildlife trafficking time and again. Total lack of political support will pave the way for easy trafficking of wildlife products and the poachers are aware of the poor enforcement laws and knows for a fact that getting away with it is as easy as anything. Poachers will continue poaching at regular intervals until and unless the laws are foolproof and anti poaching is stepped up. Better pay packages and incentives for the Forest Guard will definitely boost their moral and will lure anyone who would like to join as a forest guard. They are the shadows of protection, you chop one tree and you take away the shade and the protection similarly if they are not motivated they would not have the heart to show their best in the field. The Counter Insurgency Jungle Warfare School (CIJWS) in Vairengte in Mizoram state is considered one of the world's most prestigious anti-terrorist institutions and have trained countless defence personals from various part of the world, the forest guards should also be trained to boost their moral and their fighting spirit. When endangered wildlife and it's habitats come under unprecedented pressure it's time to act with force rather than thinking about it.

Park Ranger Sean Willmore from Australia came up with a Documentary called the "The Thin Green Line" that offers a grim insight into the perils facing those policing national parks and other ecologically important areas.Willmore's efforts have not gone in vain he has the backing of many global organizations including the International Ranger Federation which helped compile an extensive report on the dangers that the forest defenders are facing worldwide. Please go through this site for more information http://www.theecologist.org/pages/archive_detail.asp?content_id=1965

We are loosing the battle and the animals are running out of space, if we still need time to think about taking some drastic steps and still more time to act on, we would've lost the battle to save our last remaining forests even before we would realise. I would like to sum up with Willmore's words, ‘It’s no longer a question of whether force can be used,’ argues Willmore, ‘but how much force.’ Appreciate your time in going through the mail.

Thanks & Regards,

Siddhartha Kr Gogoi

Good article.

India needs better and efficient judiciary system and less bureaucracy.

Haroldo Castro

Journalist, Brazil

Nice story Malini.



Well done!


Great job.


good u r becoming a disaster management expert....

Kind Regards / Mit freundlichen Grüßen

Rana Mathew

Corporate Communications


I went through your two reports. They are factually correct and your analysis is good.

Thanking you,


S.K.Chakrabarti I.F.S (R)

Consultant & Advisor, Forestry, Wildlife and Ecotourism.

Former Principal Chief Conservator of Forests &

Chief Wildlife Warden, Karnataka.

Good for you and Bengal Tigers. Congratulations on getting a chance to do all these things. Take care and continue the good work. Shanthi

Dear Malini,

Very well presented

- as a footnote to the article, I would like you to know that on 20th Feb 20111 hundreds of whales stranded on the NZ coast and on 22nd Feb 2011 the Christchurch city of NZ was razed by a massive earthquake killing 160 people.




Hi Malini,

The Article portrays very well the problems faced by wildlife due to human disturbance. I however feel that we have to draw a clear line between a true Tribal (indigenous people) and any forest dweller, I strongly believe that its the people outside the protected area who are more responsible for habitat shrinkage than a Tribal who has so far been living alongside the forests without any harm to wildlife. They have a far better idea of coexisting with the wildlife than anyone else this again is not entirely true in the case of the Lisu Tribe in Namdapha as they are responsible for great habitat loss along with the animals. A true Tribal is never a wanton killer like a Tiger which kills only to survive but the same cannot be true in the case of non-forest dwellers who have come to settle down either inside or on the fringes of the forest, they are far more responsible for wildlife destruction through incessant poaching, creating huge farmlands, assisting organised poaching gangs, rapid development, cattle grazing and so on.

It definitely makes sense no doubt to relocate Tribals from inside core areas to the fringes to make more space for the animals but it definitely does not go a long way in ensuring a healthy tiger population untill and unless the villagers non-tribals are brainwashed to protect and preserve the wildlife. A village only grows in leaps and bounds but a Tribal settlement never does.

An example, some of the Tribes like Jenu Kurubas (honey-gatherers), the Betta Kurubas (hill tribes) and the Hakki-Pikki (bird trappers) are never known to decimate any forms of wildlife but the villagers along with the countless irreponsible resort owners settling in Mudumalai from different places are definitely without a doubt are responsible for the development leading to the vast destruction of the habitat. These are my purely thoughts.

Thanks & Regards,


Thanks. Good research.


S.A. Hussain, Wildlife Institute of India

Thank you.


Nice story,



Thank you for the URL link. I enjoyed reading the article. Regards. Bharat Bhushan (http://www.upiasia.com/Blogosphere/Malini/20081217/capital_punishment_is_an_emotional_reaction/)

Hi Malini,

This is really a good and enlightening writeup, infact the first i have seen wherein the cause of the patroling team has been taken up and also it is very good that you have appreciated the efforts of those who have taken extra efforts !!

Keep up the good work !

Cheers, Gaitri Hingorani

Dear Malini,

Thank you for mailing me the link to the article.

I read the article and found it very interesting. In fact, it gives a good idea of what is going on so far from our homes.

I am sure the article would have had greater depth if only mountain sickness did not overtake you!

With good wishes.

Yeshvanth Kumar

Good and interesting piece. Yeah, we really could do with diverse agriculture ... John Swamy

Re: my latest article ... Sansar Chand acquitted again

Hey this is terrible !! I mean guys like this are much smarter than most of us who are educated and law abiding...Gaitri Hingorani

Dear Malini,

Hi, It was a pleasant surprise to receive a mail from you.So finally you have brought to the notice of the public the facts,we sure do need people like you who are fearless and not scared to tell the facts.

Navita Kapoor

Dear Ms Shankar,

You have done an incredible job and we appreciate your commitment to undertake a concerted media campaign on UNCCD issues. We hope this doesn’t discourage you because your achievements, which speak for themselves, should still enable you to raise the required funds without any external endorsements. Given your passion for this issue and the quality of your work, I have no doubt that there will be other ways to support your work.

We wish you success in the fund-raising and implementation of your work.

Best wishes,

Wagaki Wischnewski

Public information and Media Officer

UNCCD Secretariat

Platz der Vereinten Nationen 1

Bonn, Germany

Dear Malini,

What talented you are! Thanks for everything you’ve done not only for us but also for the digital discourse foundation. They are fortunate to work with you.

Mekong Eyes’ very happy to be a part of your trip in Vietnam and pleased to see many pictures, videos of Mekong Delta on youtube and blog.

Of course we will share these information on our online channel and give it a like (me already ^-^)

All behalf of Mekong Eyes Company, I wish you all health, happiness and success.

Kind regards,

Thoa Tran (Ms.)

Sales Consultant.

Mekong Eyes Cruise

Can Tho | Vietnam

Name: Digital Discourse Foundation

URL: https://www.digitaldiscourse.org.in

Address: # 1 / 1 Police Station Road,



Karnataka, India

Pin: 560004

Tel: +91 80 26677090

Cellphone (s): +919448055645 / +919900604440 / +919844253935

Email: director@digitaldiscourse.org.in; directordigitaldiscourse@gmail.com